Ontwikkeling

  • Vergroot lettergrootte
  • Standaard lettergrootte
  • Verklein lettergrootte
Home Rechtspraak DNA en de rol van DNA in het strafproces De rol van DNA in het strafproces

De rol van DNA in het strafproces

E-mail Afdrukken PDF
 

De rol van DNA in het strafproces

drs.J.W.Swaen Historicus www.blikopdewereld.nl

 


 


 In de zogenaamde A4 kranten reeks ( een project van de bladen NRC, Volkskrant, Algemeen Dagblad en Trouw in samenwerking met educatieve uitgeverij Thieme Meulenhoff) is ook een A4 krant verschenen over opsporingsmethoden

A4-krant: Opsporingsmethoden

2 februari 2004

Undercoveracties, infiltratie, pseudokoop, inkijkoperaties, DNA-onderzoek, camera's, sectie, afluisteren en aftappen, scanners. Het zijn allemaal hulpmiddelen voor de opsporing van criminelen. En omdat de roep om harder optreden en strenger straffen luider wordt, mogen politie en justitie er steeds ruimer gebruik van maken. In deze A4-krant lees je van alles over de mogelijkheden en hulpmiddelen die er zijn om criminelen voor de rechter te krijgen. En over de maatschappelijke discussies die daarmee samenhangen.




DNA: sporen naar de toekomst
 

Dit is de internetsite van de Landelijke Projectgroep die door de Minister van Justitie is ingesteld voor de implementatie van de op 1 november 2001 in werking getreden "Wijziging van de Regeling van DNA-Onderzoek in Strafzaken". U kunt hier informatie vinden over de juridische en technisch-wetenschappelijke ontwikkelingen op het gebied van forensisch DNA-onderzoek in Nederland en daarbuiten.

Een meer dan uitstekende site.

In de rubriek DNA project komen aan de orde:

Doel en organisatie, regelgeving, Rechtelijke macht , politie, Oude zaken, NFI, Ketenautomatisering.

In de rubriek DNA dossier komen aan de orde:

Nieuws, DNAardigheden, Literatuur, Wet en regelgeving, Links, Verslag Symposium, Thema's.

In de rubriek DNA vragen komen aan de orde:

Landelijke projectgroep, Wet en regelgeving, DNA onderzoek, DNA databank

Zie ook de uitstekende site van de BBC over 50 jaar geschiedenis van DNA

 

Twenty Years of DNA evidence

New DNA test to solve more cases

Crime-fighting successes of DNA

A new way to interpret DNA samples has been announced by the Forensic Science Service. Some high-profile cases have been solved by DNA evidence:

 

LYNDA MANN AND DAWN ASHWORTH

The first murder conviction using DNA evidence came in 1988 when baker Colin Pitchfork was found guilty of the separate murders of two schoolgirls - Lynda Mann and Dawn Ashworth, both 15 - in Narborough, Leicestershire.

DNA
Advancements in DNA technology led to Pitchfork's conviction

Both of the cases - one in 1983 and one in 1986 - involved sexual assaults, and semen samples were taken from both bodies.

Police had been convinced that local man Richard Buckland had committed both crimes and, under questioning, he confessed to the later murder but said he had no involvement in the first.

It was because of officers' belief that Mr Buckland had killed both girls that Leicester University's Dr Alec Jeffreys, who had developed a technique for creating DNA profiles, was called in.

After comparing semen samples with Mr Buckland's blood sample, Mr Jeffreys conclusively proved that both girls had been killed by the same man, but that it had not been Mr Buckland.

After the world's first mass screening for DNA - where 5,000 men in three villages were asked to volunteer blood or saliva samples - Pitchfork was eventually caught and jailed in 1988.

 

PETER FALCONIO

On 14 July 2001, Bradley Murdoch, of Broome, Western Australia, flagged down British backpackers Peter Falconio and Joanne Lees in their camper van in Alice Springs.

Bradley Murdoch
Murdoch consistently denied responsibility for the killing

He shot Mr Falconio dead and pointed a gun at Miss Lees before tying her up. She later escaped.

During the investigation that followed, the UK's FSS team carried out DNA tests on hand ties used on Miss Lee.

A DNA profile was obtained from "deep inside the home-made ties" thanks to the relatively new technology of DNA Low Copy Number (DNA LCN).

DNA LCN means DNA profiles can be obtained from samples containing only a few cells, as with the hand ties.

In 2005, in the court case that led to Murdoch's conviction, the jury heard that the genetic sample obtained from the handcuffs was 100 million times more likely to have come from Murdoch than anyone else.

 

MARION CROFTS

In 1981, Marion Crofts, 14, was dragged from her bicycle as she rode to band practice in Aldershot, Hampshire, and beaten to death. She had also been raped and strangled.

Marion Crofts
Marion Crofts was killed in 1981

Despite a major investigation, it was not until two decades later, and thanks to advances in forensic evidence gathering, that there was a major breakthrough.

In July 1999, a full DNA profile of Marino's killer was obtained using DNA LCN.

It was extracted from microscope slide samples which had been taken from Marion's body and sealed in 1981. The process was risky - if the tests had failed, the samples could not be used again.

The DNA profile was entered into the national DNA database, but there were no matches.

In April 2001, Leicester man Tony Jasinskyj was arrested and charged for allegedly assaulting his wife. He was routinely swabbed for DNA and the profile entered into the database.

It turned out to be a match for the profile of Marion's killer and he was subsequently jailed for life in 2002.

 

MICHAEL LITTLE

Michael Little, 53, died when a brick smashed into the cab of his 40-tonne lorry as he drove on the M3 in Surrey in March 2003.

Craig Harman
Craig Harman admitted manslaughter after giving DNA

DNA taken from a brick thrown through Mr Little's cab was checked against the national database.

A relative of Craig Harman, of Frimley, inadvertently led police to their man after officers used the pioneering familial searching technique.

Familial searches, which are based on the fact that individuals who are related are more likely to have similar DNA, had been launched a few months before.

The DNA profile from the brick was checked against the national database, but because Harman did not have a criminal record no match came up.

Using the technique, 25 people with similar DNA were located and Harman's relative was top of the list. Harman was then caught after giving a DNA sample which matched exactly.

In April 2004, Harman, then 19, pleaded guilty to manslaughter, becoming the first person in the world to be successfully prosecuted using familial searching.

Story from BBC NEWS:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/2/hi/uk_news/5405470.stm


 

Literatuurlijst:DNA in het strafproces

Eikelboom Siem:De genetische vingerafdruk; de waarde van DNA als opsporingsmiddel ISBN 9020460323

Ferllini Roxana:Silent Witness: How Forensic Antropology is used to solve The world 's toughust crimes ISBN 1552976246

Miller Hugh: Sporen van schuld; De technische recherche en haar strijd tegen de misdaad ISBN 9024603528

Platt Richard: Crime Scene: Handboek voor forensisch onderzoek; ISBN 9077692010

Post Hans: Bloed zweet en kogels; De wetenschap als rechercheur ISBN 9068341707

 

 

 
15-10-06 drs.J.W.Swaen www.blikopdewereld.nl
 

Wie is online

We hebben 23 gasten online

Zoekfunctie

Thrillers & fantasy boeken (234x60)

De Dood als Machtsmiddel

cover boek

Dit boek gaat over de Dood als Machtsmiddel, Moord en Doodslag door verpleegkundigen. Het proces tegen Lucia de Berk, de Haagse verpleegkundige die tot levenslang werd veroordeeld, zonder directe bewijzen, leidde ertoe dat ik een onderzoek startte naar het voorkomen van Moord en Doodslag door verpleegkundigen. Dit onderzoek betreft een vijftal strafzaken in Nederland en een aantal strafzaken in Duitsland, België, Oostenrijk/Zwitserland en Engeland. Uitgeverij Boekscout ISBN 9789088346798 prijs € 17,95. Men kan het ook bij mij bestellen.